Munich
Munich (2005)

Munich

2/5
(21 votos)
7.5IMDb74Metascore

Detalles

Elenco

Errores

When dialing the phone number of the bomb-trapped phone for the second time, Carl begins with a different digit than he did the first time he called.

The team meets in an underground room to debrief the team leader.

Along the far wall, behind the reel-to-reel tape recorder, is a water cooler with a polycarbonate bottle.

At the time, water coolers had glass bottles.

When Avner meets Andreas and his friend Tony in a Rome café, there is a huge statue of 'Queen Victoria' (qv), in her extremely distinctive pose, in the middle of the square, with the British coat of arms on the pedestal, betraying the location as Malta.

When Avner is leaving his apartment in New York, a yellow "rubber bumper" MGB is present in the line of cars on the side of the street.

The federally mandated rubber energy absorption bumpers were not installed on MGBs until late summer of 1974 as a 1974/5 model.

The age of Avner's daughter would seem to suggest this scene takes place sometime before then.

When Avner and Ephraim are walking along the beach in Tel Aviv, the sea is to the left and the sun is casting shadows towards the camera, revealing that they are walking north.

The scene must have been shot on the east coast of Malta, not in Tel Aviv, on Israel's west coast.

When Avner finds Carl dead and naked in the bed and moves his head, you can see Carl's eyes moving about four times.

When Jeanette the Dutch Assassin is dead and nearly naked in her chair, the reflection on her chest reveals that she is breathing.

'Golda Meir' (qv) wishes "mazel tov" to Avner's unborn daughter.

(So do team members at their first meal together.

) Sayng "mazel tov" on an unborn baby is bad luck.

When Avner and Ephraim are walking along the beach in the middle of the film, a jet-ski appears in the water.

Jet-skis were invented in 1976.

At the beginning of the movie, the Munich Olympic kidnappings are on TV.

Actors are watching the footage on screen as if it was happening live, but the date of the events is displayed on the ABC news coverage.

The news footage is clearly archive footage.

When leaving Papa's farm, the camera and two operators are reflected on the side of the car.

Outside the hotel in London, a taxi goes over a speed bump, which wouldn't have been there in the 1970s.

When Avner and his crew are in Rome, you can see a 2000-style trash can.

Toward the end of the movie, Daphna's hand touching Avner's face.

It's in a different position in three different shots.

Steve and an Italian girl observe the first victim in Rome from an Alfa Romeo Giulia (model 1974 or later, with a straight trunk).

When the victim walks through the street, putting on his coat, Steve and the girl drive away in a Lancia Flavia.

When the victim is in the store, they arrive in the Alfa Romeo Giulia.

Though they took the time to digitally add the World Trade Center to the final shot, they didn't edit out the Citigroup Center, Trump World Tower, and the Bloomberg building, which were built after the time of the movie.

When Avner and Ephraim are walking along the beach, they pass 'Joe Quattromani' (qv) twice.

The first time, nothing is on the ground near him.

The second time, he is next to a briefcase.

When Avner walks into Papa's home, he walks towards the kitchen past a table.

There is a man standing next to the table talking to someone sitting down but in the next shot, the man standing up is gone.

When the crew eats for the first time together, Steve holds up his plate for Avner to put some meat on it.

In the next shot, Steve's plate is on the table as Avner serves him the meat.

At the end of the film, when Avner's wife Daphna touches his face, her nails are polished.

After they have sex, her nails are not polished.

The shop the victim in Rome enters has modern San Pellegrino cans.

When Avner and one of his team members find their mate stabbed to death on the bench near the river, a modern-day truck, with a spoiler and cooling unit on the roof, passes by on the bridge above.

When walking on the waterfront in Tel Aviv, a rusty beat-up 1972-79 VW Bus appears on the street.

The scene takes place in late 1972.

A brand-new first year model would not be that beat up and rusty after just a few months.

The reel-to-reel tape recorder used in the debriefing is a Revox B77, which came on the market in 1978.

When Avner checks his TV, he is holding a MagLite in his mouth.

The first MagLite was introduced in 1979, and the model he's holding was introduced in 1984.

Israeli weightlifter Yossef Romano is portrayed as a fit man who attempts a rescue, which eventually results in his death.

At the time of the kidnapping, Romano was injured, and walking with crutches.

When the first Palestinian victim (the translator of 1001 Nights) turns at the corner at his house, right before his assassination (around the 37th minute of the movie) a modern parking meter is visible with a sign of a cellular phone.

After being shot, the first victim falls face-first onto his grocery bag.

In the next scene, he is lying face up.

When Avner and his wife are making love in New York, he is drenched in sweat and his hair is soaking wet.

His wife wipes his face and his wet hair is visible.

In the next shot, his hair is dry.

When Avner is waiting for the Palestinian's daughter and wife to come out of their building, before letting off the telephone bomb, the little girl says the same line twice.

Off-screen, she says hello to her driver before she actually meets him.

She comes out, repeats the same line, and says hello to the driver when she meets him.

The black Mercedes W114 230.

6 used by the KGB agents during the Greece assassination scene is patched together to make it more "historic.

" The front doors were made to look like a Series 1 model, with divided side windows, made prior August 1973.

The side mirror was removed completely.

The rest of the car is clearly a Series 2 (post August 1973), including the model designation 230.

6 itself (it should read just "230", the two different models 230.

4 and 230.

6 co-existed after August 1973).

In Brooklyn, Avner walks past a wheelchair-accessible curb cut, which didn't exist in 1972.

In Greece, just before the large explosion, Avner, who is supposed to be fluent in German, asks "Kann ich ein Licht haben?" as he asks for a light for his cigarette.

The person responds "sind Sie Deutscher?" ("Are you German?").

The correct question is, "Kann ich Feuer haben?" In the film, the German snipers at the airport were using rifles with telescopic sights.

In reality, the Germans were criticized for their lack of preparation, including the fact that none of the snipers had telescopic or infrared sights.

When the team is eating dinner after the assassination where Avner is nearly blown up in the adjoining room, the scene begins with a white rug under the table and then the rug is mystically gone in the later scene and bare wood floors are seen.

At the shootout at the airport at the end of the movie one of the terrorists machine guns the first group of hostages in the first helicopter, throws a grenade into it, and takes off running.

In the wide shot of the helicopters when it shows the one on the left exploding, you can see the terrorist who threw the grenade running to the other helicopter and his body is hit with several bullets.

In the next scene, that same terrorist is running toward the camera and again he gets hit by the bullets.

Late in the film Avner makes a telephone call from a booth on a street apparently in Brooklyn.

He gives the phone's area code as 212.

This was correct at the time the movie was set - Brooklyn changed to the 718 area code in 1984.

Just before the terrorist with the cowboy hat (Tony), shoots one of the athletes through the cheek, we see a terrorist in a denim jacket and beige ski mask looking on in the background.

As the shot goes to a different angle we see a different terrorist in a yellow shirt threatening an athlete (out of shot).

Avner's wedding ring is a different style late in the movie compared to earlier.

When Avner and Ephraim are walking along the sea front in Israel, modern Maltese phone boxes and buses are visible in the background.

When Avner is on the airplane to Geneva, the flight number starts with SA, for South African Airways, which has never flown to Geneva.

In one scene a chess game is briefly visible in the foreground.

It is turned the wrong way, with a black square, rather than a white square, in the lower right corner.

Just before the credits roll, Avner asks probing questions of Ephraim.

They are in a small park on the north end of Gantry Plaza State Park, near 48th.

& Center Blvd.

, just north of Avalon Riverview, Queens West, Long Island City.

SSE across the East River are the high-rises of Peter Cooper Village behind Avner and to his left (our right), and the low-rises of Stuyvesant Town directly behind him.

The World Trade Center towers have not been digitally added to these shots - "Break bread with me, Ephraim" - but have been added to the pullback about a minute later.

When Avner and Louis are leaving Papa's house after their meeting, they are both seen entering the back seats of the car and sitting down.

But in the next shot only Avner can be seen in the back of the car.

When Carl goes into the apartment building lobby to "sweep" the scene of the first assassination, he picks up a spent shell casing that is clearly a.

22 Caliber shell.

The assassins were both armed with Beretta M1951 model pistols, which fire 9mm.

(Interestingly, the actual assassins in real life likely used Beretta Model 70s, which do fire.

22 Caliber.

) The term "honey trap," which is used in the film, was first coined by John LeCarre in 1974 (publication of Tinker Tailor), so it's very unlikely (we don't have the exact time line of that incident in the movie, or indications of reading habits) that it would have been used.

Box Office

FechaÁreaBruto
26 March 2006 USA USD 47,379,090
19 March 2006 USA USD 47,290,275
12 March 2006 USA USD 47,113,190
5 March 2006 USA USD 46,731,905
26 February 2006 USA USD 46,079,435
19 February 2006 USA USD 45,415,655
12 February 2006 USA USD 44,313,605
5 February 2006 USA USD 42,960,295
29 January 2006 USA USD 40,647,785
22 January 2006 USA USD 37,985,445
15 January 2006 USA USD 33,807,605
8 January 2006 USA USD 25,350,740
1 January 2006 USA USD 15,949,005
25 December 2005 USA USD 6,040,860
USA USD 47,403,685
26 February 2006 UK GBP 4,719,662
19 February 2006 UK GBP 4,426,255
12 February 2006 UK GBP 3,779,184
5 February 2006 UK GBP 2,814,506
29 January 2006 UK GBP 1,209,970
worldwide USD 130,358,911
Non-USA USD 82,955,226
21 March 2006 Argentina ARS 594,476
14 March 2006 Argentina ARS 577,512
7 March 2006 Argentina ARS 554,166
28 February 2006 Argentina ARS 510,671
21 February 2006 Argentina ARS 446,836
14 February 2006 Argentina ARS 401,051
7 February 2006 Argentina ARS 283,625
31 January 2006 Argentina ARS 127,399
5 March 2006 Netherlands EUR 1,378,764
29 January 2006 Netherlands EUR 314,480
2006 Romania USD 81,622
FechaÁreaBrutoPantalla
25 December 2005 USA USD 6,040,860 532
29 January 2006 UK GBP 1,209,970 383
31 January 2006 Argentina ARS 127,399 40
27 January 2006 Australia USD 1,342,115 211
27 January 2006 Austria USD 135,189
27 January 2006 Belgium USD 276,037
27 January 2006 Brazil USD 779,615 200
10 February 2006 Denmark USD 94,538
27 January 2006 Europe USD 9,701,725 2034
10 February 2006 Finland USD 53,937
27 January 2006 France USD 2,357,012
27 January 2006 Germany USD 1,394,057
17 February 2006 Hong Kong USD 183,761 22
27 January 2006 Iceland USD 21,319
27 January 2006 Italy USD 1,345,479
29 January 2006 Netherlands EUR 314,480 71
10 February 2006 Norway USD 77,071
3 February 2006 South Africa USD 85,221 45
27 January 2006 Spain USD 1,378,266
10 February 2006 Sweden USD 118,147
27 January 2006 Switzerland USD 293,543
27 January 2006 Turkey USD 426,699
FechaÁreaBrutoPantalla
26 March 2006 USA USD 50,460 82
19 March 2006 USA USD 93,405 105
12 March 2006 USA USD 230,850 171
5 March 2006 USA USD 449,605 281
26 February 2006 USA USD 502,355 325
19 February 2006 USA USD 801,890 380
12 February 2006 USA USD 783,510 546
5 February 2006 USA USD 1,675,150 1,151
29 January 2006 USA USD 1,670,810 980
22 January 2006 USA USD 3,032,070 1,437
15 January 2006 USA USD 5,909,760 1,498
8 January 2006 USA USD 7,566,075
1 January 2006 USA USD 6,436,850
25 December 2005 USA USD 6,040,860 532
26 February 2006 UK GBP 124,937 159
19 February 2006 UK GBP 316,688 290
12 February 2006 UK GBP 521,566 341
5 February 2006 UK GBP 876,900 381
29 January 2006 UK GBP 1,209,970 383
21 March 2006 Argentina ARS 10,435 32
14 March 2006 Argentina ARS 14,791 37
7 March 2006 Argentina ARS 26,748 40
28 February 2006 Argentina ARS 42,146 40
21 February 2006 Argentina ARS 45,785 40
14 February 2006 Argentina ARS 49,337 40
7 February 2006 Argentina ARS 95,122 40
31 January 2006 Argentina ARS 127,399 40
5 March 2006 Netherlands EUR 80,730 72
29 January 2006 Netherlands EUR 314,480 71

Comentarios

I love Eric Bana and Stephen Spielberg most of the time, but this is not history. The argument has been made that, though the history may be flawed, the film should be judged on it's artistic merits.

Steven Spielberg knows how to make a movie. He has such a knowledge and understanding of the medium that is truly unparallelled.

I don't usually write reviews on IMDb.com but after seeing this, I felt compelled to so here goes.

I first saw the movie when it came out in theaters in December 2005, and was ultimately forgotten by me, until I decided to buy it on DVD two and a half years later and watched it again. And I found that the movie was highly enjoyable, entertaining, and something that I could easily watch again and again just for the character interaction.

The movie works at different levels. At the surface, it feels almost like a thriller action movie, but when you start enjoying that aspect of it, you question the enjoyment since the movie is based on real life assassinations.

Spielberg wasn´t a big favorite of mine due to personal likeness, because i really think that he is a great Filmmaker and a true influence, but sadly over the years he turned to be very commercial and too blockbuster for my style, sadly his favorite film of mine, the timeless classic Jaws, was the movie to guilt about the stupid blockbuster culture of cinema that´s the reality these daysI always enjoyed dark stuff, and when Spielberg stops doing that fancy "Family Friendly" movies, and puts certain horrid scenes like the melted nazis or maybe even true godly movies like Saving Private Ryan, i enjoy that a lot.

...and I'll just give you a two word synopsis of this move.

5 minutes into Munich, and Spielberg proves that he is one of the most gripping directors in this lavish, rich, and textured drama. The tragedy of the 1972 Munich Olympics is realistically portrayed in a gruesome and unapologetic fashion.

Over the years, I keep coming back to this film more and more. To be sure, Spielberg's movies are expertly crafted, usually on point with all the components working like a finely tuned watch - some exceptions like Crystal Skull stand out.

Comentarios