A Beautiful Mind
A Beautiful Mind (2001)

A Beautiful Mind

3/5
(85 votos)
8.2IMDb72Metascore

Detalles

Elenco

Errores

In 1951 'John Nash (V)' (qv) drinks from a paper cup with the "recycled" symbol on it.

The symbol didn't come into use until much later.

The light switch on the wall in 'John Nash (V)' (qv) and 'Alicia Nash' (qv)'s house is of a modern design.

In the 1950s, 'Alicia Nash' (qv) is shown in her kitchen with a Tupperware Wonderlier covered bowl that wasn't available until the 1970s.

In 'John Nash (V)' (qv)'s neighborhood during the 1950s, one of the houses has a modern-day plastic telephone box on the outside.

The baby's pacifier shown on the floor is clearly a Nuk orthodontic pacifier.

This brand (made by Gerber) was not made available in the US until well into the 1960s.

A plastic laundry basket appears in a scene taking place in the 1950s.

When 'Alicia Nash' (qv) gives 'John Nash (V)' (qv) his medicine, she places it on a piece of newspaper from where it disappears and reappears before he takes it.

When the pens are being placed on 'John Nash (V)' (qv)'s table, they switch from being perpendicular to Nash to being parallel.

In 1994 when 'John Nash (V)' (qv) is talking to the man about the Nobel Prize nomination and they are drinking tea, yellow packets of Splenda are clearly visible on the table.

Splenda was not available in the U.

until 1998.

The way 'John Nash (V)' (qv) is holding his briefcase changes between shots during the pen presentation.

When 'John Nash (V)' (qv) says that perhaps he should return to the hospital, he takes 'Alicia Nash' (qv)'s hand twice between shots.

In Nash's first lecture, the formula on the chalkboard changes between shots.

An "f" changes to "F" and a superscript "3" appears.

The aerial view of the Pentagon includes the modern-day helicopter landing pad.

There is no "ceremony of the pens" at Princeton University.

As 'John Nash (V)' (qv) is talking to Martin Hansen in his office, the reflection of the boom can be seen in the frame of the picture in the background When Nash is talking to the man about the Nobel Prize nomination and they are drinking tea, the spoon in the man's hand disappears and reappears between shots.

When 'Alicia Nash' (qv) puts the medicine on the newspaper it is flat, but in the next shot one of the tablets is standing upwards.

In the first classroom scene, the movable blackboard is in a different raised position between shots.

Since the first outdoor scene at Princeton was filmed in winter, but is supposed to take place in the fall, CGI leaves were put on the trees.

But the shadow of the trees have no leaves on them.

When Alicia drinks a glass of water in the bathroom she empties the glass.

Cut to the next shot she splashes the wall with a good amount of water and then throws the glass, breaking it.

When 'Alicia Nash' (qv) is comforting 'John Nash (V)' (qv) after his delusional breakdown at Princeton, she holds her hand out, and Nash places his left hand in hers.

Next scene, he places his hand in hers again.

When 'John Nash (V)' (qv) is giving his speech at the Nobel Ceremony, the embroidery on the handkerchief in his pocket is visible then not visible between shots.

In the first scene in his dorm room at Princeton, set in 1947, 'John Nash (V)' (qv) listens to a recording by the early-music ensemble Gothic Voices featuring soprano 'Emma Kirkby' (qv).

The recording, of 'Hildegard von Bingen' (qv)'s "Columba aspexit," was not made until 1981; in fact, Emma Kirkby was not even born until 1949.

'Silvia Drottning' (qv) (The Queen of Sweden) is not blonde but has black hair and 'King Carl XVI Gustaf' (qv) of Sweden is not shorter than her.

When 'John Nash (V)' (qv) arrives at MIT after having come from the pentagon he is wearing a topcoat though everyone complains about the air-conditioning is broken and it followed by a scene in which opening windows because of the heat facilitates the film's "meet cute".

However this might not be a gratuitous error but a foreshadowing of Nash's mental disturbances.

As 'John Nash (V)' (qv) walks on the Harvard campus on his way to the math conference (shortly before being chased by Rosen and his men), he drops his bag behind him to hug his roommate and the young girl.

During his conversations with them, the bag remains on the ground.

Within one second, just before Nash walks off, the bag goes from being on the ground to being clutched to his chest.

In the section set in March 1994, we see the trees a healthy green.

In New Jersey, trees are still bare in March.

After Helinger tells 'John Nash (V)' (qv) he will not receive any placement, the camera pulls back on John as he stands in the doorway.

The actor's 'T' mark can be seen on the floor to the far right of the screen where John had previously been standing.

A number of facts in 'John Nash (V)' (qv)'s life were intentionally altered for dramatic and commercial reasons.

Alfred Nobel's name is misspelled as "Noble" on the rostrum.

Even if the audience at the Nobel Prize ceremony would give a laureate a standing ovation, the Swedish 'King Carl XVI Gustaf' (qv) and his family, who sit on stage to the right, would never, ever rise.

In the Pentagon scene, where Dr.

'John Nash (V)' (qv) discovers the codes are map coordinates, one of the coordinates he reads off is "67-46-90", presumably in degrees, minutes and seconds.

But in the degree-minute-second coordinate system, seconds go up only to 59, not 90.

Contrary to what the Nobel representative claims, "the Sveriges Riksbank prize in economic sciences in memory of Alfred Nobel" is not privately funded.

It is financed by the Swedish state bank.

(The five "genuine" Nobel prizes are funded by the legacy of Alfred Nobel.

) 'John Nash (V)' (qv) didn't receive the Nobel prize alone, but with colleague Reinhard Selten and Hungarian-born János Harsányi.

"Game Theory" was initiated by Hungarian-born John von Neumann and Austrian-born Oskar Morgenstern in 1944.

Strictly speaking, 'John Nash (V)' (qv) didn't win the Nobel Prize because there isn't a prize for Economics or Mathematics.

(Alfred Nobel who willed his estate to the Nobel foundation saw no need for a prize in mathematics.

) In 1969 the Swedish Central Bank established the "The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel".

This prize is presented in the same ceremony and is therefore often mistaken for a proper Nobel Prize.

It is even often referred to as the "Nobel Prize in Economics" in daily conversation; the fictional character of President Jed Bartlet on _"The West Wing" (1999)_ (qv) was also presented as a Nobel Prize winner (for economics) with the show also not making the real-world distinctions.

When Nash and Parcher are walking to the warehouse the wide shot so well lit shows the right side of the stairway they pass as lit from behind the left wall.

On the tighter shot when they actually cross in front of that stairway there is no light on the wall at all.

Then in the wide shot again the light is there.

When the Russians are chasing Parcher and Nash in the car, one of the headlights of Parcher's is out but when they stop at the waters edge and get out both headlights are working.

On the "hot Day" when the air-conditioning isn't working, the open window reveals a tree bare of leaves, and Nash arrives at the office in a heavy overcoat.

On the wedding day the trees in the background are full of green leaves, when there is snow on the ground.

Throughout the movie, there are times when the scenery does not match the apparent season.

The students "bad" tie shows stars and double helices.

Although someone might have drawn those patterns already before the early 1950th, the double helix as scientific symbol had its breakthrough not until 1953.

Box Office

FechaÁreaBruto
27 May 2002 USA USD 170,708,996
19 May 2002 USA USD 170,498,541
12 May 2002 USA USD 170,240,036
5 May 2002 USA USD 169,852,636
28 April 2002 USA USD 169,348,761
21 April 2002 USA USD 168,418,991
14 April 2002 USA USD 167,135,186
7 April 2002 USA USD 164,988,611
31 March 2002 USA USD 160,844,681
24 March 2002 USA USD 154,704,651
17 March 2002 USA USD 149,205,356
10 March 2002 USA USD 144,274,651
3 March 2002 USA USD 138,929,921
24 February 2002 USA USD 132,688,491
17 February 2002 USA USD 125,695,006
10 February 2002 USA USD 113,271,766
3 February 2002 USA USD 104,502,101
27 January 2002 USA USD 92,887,746
20 January 2002 USA USD 77,617,141
13 January 2002 USA USD 58,420,716
6 January 2002 USA USD 37,779,241
30 December 2001 USA USD 18,559,546
23 December 2001 USA USD 2,501,096
USA USD 170,742,341
21 April 2002 UK GBP 7,514,412
14 April 2002 UK GBP 7,218,333
7 April 2002 UK GBP 6,741,069
31 March 2002 UK GBP 5,925,441
24 March 2002 UK GBP 4,966,138
17 March 2002 UK GBP 4,065,348
10 March 2002 UK GBP 2,939,667
3 March 2002 UK GBP 1,516,110
24 February 2002 UK GBP 186,862
worldwide USD 313,542,341
Non-USA USD 142,800,000
30 November 2002 Italy EUR 14,667,895
1 September 2002 Italy EUR 14,664,067
28 April 2002 Italy EUR 14,332,586
14 April 2002 Italy EUR 13,862,489
31 March 2002 Italy EUR 12,148,028
24 March 2002 Italy EUR 10,795,823
17 March 2002 Italy EUR 9,548,885
4 August 2002 Russia USD 762,834
14 April 2002 Russia RUR 11,029,312
7 April 2002 Russia RUR 10,127,951
31 March 2002 Russia RUR 8,830,234
24 March 2002 Russia RUR 7,039,852
Russia USD 762,834
31 October 2002 Spain EUR 11,887,461
10 August 2002 Spain EUR 11,620,349
FechaÁreaBrutoPantalla
23 December 2001 USA USD 2,501,096 524
24 February 2002 UK GBP 186,862 24
25 January 2002 UK USD 927,383
25 January 2002 Austria USD 107,214
25 January 2002 Belgium USD 114,831
25 January 2002 Europe USD 4,506,836 1505
25 January 2002 Finland USD 40,433
15 February 2002 France USD 977,271
25 January 2002 Germany USD 982,410
25 January 2002 Iceland USD 16,732
25 January 2002 Italy USD 1,089,489
25 January 2002 Netherlands USD 156,840
25 January 2002 Spain USD 708,753
25 January 2002 Sweden USD 110,004
25 January 2002 Switzerland USD 252,747
FechaÁreaBrutoPantalla
27 May 2002 USA USD 144,430 202
19 May 2002 USA USD 171,405 293
12 May 2002 USA USD 268,515 351
5 May 2002 USA USD 303,705 397
28 April 2002 USA USD 676,095 626
21 April 2002 USA USD 854,170 746
14 April 2002 USA USD 1,457,335 1,100
7 April 2002 USA USD 2,592,030 1,436
31 March 2002 USA USD 3,884,455 1,560
24 March 2002 USA USD 4,081,270 1,455
17 March 2002 USA USD 3,380,260 1,533
10 March 2002 USA USD 3,872,880 1,793
3 March 2002 USA USD 4,648,985 1,962
24 February 2002 USA USD 5,306,985 2,069
17 February 2002 USA USD 9,426,085 2,081
10 February 2002 USA USD 6,304,800 2,220
3 February 2002 USA USD 8,403,690 2,250
27 January 2002 USA USD 11,531,735 2,237
20 January 2002 USA USD 14,707,360 2,225
13 January 2002 USA USD 15,220,705 2,222
6 January 2002 USA USD 16,565,820 1,853
30 December 2001 USA USD 12,628,870 525
23 December 2001 USA USD 2,501,096 524
21 April 2002 UK GBP 144,065 143
14 April 2002 UK GBP 233,548 201
7 April 2002 UK GBP 351,895 269
31 March 2002 UK GBP 471,188 296
24 March 2002 UK GBP 495,346 355
17 March 2002 UK GBP 645,136 376
10 March 2002 UK GBP 839,881 379
3 March 2002 UK GBP 1,226,446 377
24 February 2002 UK GBP 186,862 24
28 April 2002 Italy EUR 93,623 39
14 April 2002 Italy EUR 579,892
31 March 2002 Italy EUR 1,354,082
17 March 2002 Italy EUR 1,810,195
14 April 2002 Russia RUR 901,360
7 April 2002 Russia RUR 1,294,889
31 March 2002 Russia RUR 1,781,351

Comentarios

Perhaps genius and neuropathy are only separated by a line. In many cases, the boundaries between them are not very clear, and schizophrenia like "a beautiful eve" is in most cases the patent of a person with a high IQ.

A beautiful,insightful and very moving film which is a joy to watch. The script and direction are superb and the film zips along at a 'page-turning' rate which will continually have you asking 'what happens next' as it is a rolled up thriller, love story and biography in one.

(A beautiful mind) the best film I've seen in my entire life. It leaves a message so beautiful: when you propose to do something, you must never surrender and what exactly did John was fighting for ignoring their hallucinations.

The story of genius is not scarce in the movie world, but A Beautiful Mind touches the heart is that it gives a fatal flaw to the genius. The solution to this defect is not by any IQ or drugs, but by human love.

What criteria should we judge a biopic on? How true to life it is, or how well it works as a standalone movie?

A thousand reader with a thousand hamurate. In my opinion, mind here refers to the brain.

This film is beautiful, heartfelt and emotional. A Beautiful Mind tells the story of John Nash perfectly and Russell Crowe plays him outstandingly.

By the time Russell Crowe (as John Nash) married Jennifer Connelly (as Alicia), I had serious concerns about "A Beautiful Mind". My first question revolved around Mr.

Comentarios